Unmasking Anonymous Online Defamers in Malaysia: The Norwich Pharmacal Principle and Social Media Defamation
- Messrs Lui & Bhullar
- 4 days ago
- 3 min read
BY MESSRS LUI & BHULLAR
Unmasking Anonymous Online Defamers in Malaysia: The Norwich Pharmacal Principle and Social Media Defamation
In an era dominated by digital communication, the threat of online defamation and social media defamation in Malaysia is more serious than ever. Whether it's a false accusation posted on Facebook, a malicious video shared on TikTok, or a fake review on Google, defamatory content spreads fast—and often anonymously.
When the identity of the wrongdoer is hidden behind a screen name or a pseudonymous account, victims are left wondering how to pursue legal action for defamation in Malaysia. Fortunately, the law provides a remedy. One of the most powerful legal tools available is the Norwich Pharmacal Order (NPO), based on the landmark English case Norwich Pharmacal Co. & Ors. v. Customs and Excise Commissioners [1974] AC 133.
What is a Norwich Pharmacal Order?
In that case, the House of Lords held that a third party—who is not the wrongdoer but is “mixed up” in the wrongdoing—may be compelled to disclose information that can identify the real tortfeasor. As Lord Reid stated:
“If through no fault of his own a person gets mixed up in the tortious acts of others so as to facilitate their wrongdoing... he comes under a duty to assist the person who has been wronged by giving him full information and disclosing the identity of the wrongdoers.”
This principle has since been adopted in common law jurisdictions, including Malaysia, to help victims of tortious conduct such as defamation of character in Malaysia, especially when the defamer hides behind online anonymity.
Application to Social Media and Online Defamation in Malaysia
Imagine the following scenarios:
A defamatory tweet falsely accuses a company of fraud, damaging its reputation.
A viral TikTok video implies a businesswoman is involved in unethical dealings, leading to public backlash.
A fake Google review rates a restaurant 1 star, alleging food poisoning, with no factual basis.
A WhatsApp message circulates in a community group, falsely claiming a teacher was fired for misconduct.
In all these examples, the defamer uses a pseudonym or anonymous account. Victims are left with no name to sue—only a URL or a username. This is where a Norwich Pharmacal Order becomes critical.
How Does a Norwich Pharmacal Order Work in Malaysia?
To pursue a civil suit for defamation in Malaysia, the victim must first identify the perpetrator. If that information is held by a third party—such as Meta (Facebook/Instagram), Google, or TikTok—the victim may apply to the High Court for an order compelling that platform to disclose the identity of the user.
To obtain a Norwich Pharmacal Order, the applicant must show that:
A wrong has been committed (e.g., social media defamation).
The respondent (e.g., the social media company) is involved or mixed up in the wrongdoing by virtue of having control of relevant information (e.g., IP address, email used to register account).
The applicant needs the information to take legal action against the actual wrongdoer.
This application is usually made ex parte (without the other party present), with supporting affidavit evidence and urgency.
Legal and Practical Considerations
No Liability on Third Party: The third party (such as a platform or ISP) does not incur liability for the defamatory act but must assist in righting the wrong.
Cost Compensation: As Lord Reid suggested, if disclosing the information causes the platform reasonable expense, the victim may need to reimburse them.
Privacy vs Justice: Courts balance the user's right to privacy against the victim’s right to seek redress for reputational harm.
Why This Matters for Victims of Online Defamation in Malaysia
In many online defamation cases, the hardest part is not proving the falsity of the statement—it’s proving who posted it. Without that information, there can be no effective legal action for defamation in Malaysia.
At Messrs Lui & Bhullar, our experienced defamation lawyers in KL, Malaysia, regularly assist clients in filing Norwich Pharmacal applications. We liaise with technology platforms, draft persuasive affidavits, and act swiftly to preserve evidence before it’s deleted or altered.
Our Social Media and Online Defamation Legal Services Include:
Assessing the viability of a civil suit for defamation
Filing Norwich Pharmacal Orders to unmask anonymous defamers
Sending letters of demand for retractions and compensation
Applying for interim injunctions to remove defamatory content
Litigating libel and slander cases in Malaysian courts
Advising on social media defamation involving influencers, businesses, and private individuals
Conclusion: Justice in the Digital Age
Online defamation may be swift and anonymous—but it is not beyond the reach of the law. Thanks to legal mechanisms like the Norwich Pharmacal Order, victims can take meaningful steps to reclaim their reputation, even in the fast-paced world of social media.
If you're unsure how to sue for defamation in Malaysia or need to identify the person behind defamatory online content, consult our legal team today. At Messrs Lui & Bhullar, we combine strong legal strategy with digital expertise to hold online defamers accountable.
📧 Email: general@luibhullar.com
📞 WhatsApp: +60143000960 / +60143000970
Comments