Challenging Maintenance Fee Discrepancies in Strata Developments: Legal Impact of the Menara Rajawali Case

BY MESSRS LUI BHULLAR

Challenging Maintenance Fee Discrepancies in Strata Developments: Legal Impact of the Menara Rajawali Case

The Strata Management Act 2013 (SMA) governs the management and maintenance of stratified properties in Malaysia, setting clear responsibilities for Joint Management Bodies (JMB) and Management Corporations (MC). Central to these responsibilities is the fair imposition and collection of maintenance fees and sinking fund contributions. Yet, disputes continue to arise over how these fees are calculated, especially in mixed-use strata developments. One landmark case that reshaped the legal interpretation of these fee structures is the Menara Rajawali case.

Case Overview: Menara Rajawali and Unequal Fee Structures

Menara Rajawali is a mixed-use strata property development that includes residential, retail, and car park parcels. During the first Annual General Meeting (AGM) of its Joint Management Committee (JMC) in June 2016, a resolution was passed to adopt different rates of maintenance charges based on parcel types:

• Residential and retail units: RM2.80 per share unit

• Car park units: RM1.68 per share unit

A residential parcel owner challenged this resolution, arguing it was discriminatory and in violation of the Strata Management Act 2013. The legal challenge was directed against both the JMB and Denflow Sdn Bhd, the owner of the car park parcels.

High Court: Initial Dismissal of Challenge

The High Court dismissed the plaintiff’s challenge in 2018, holding that the SMA did not prohibit JMBs from setting different maintenance rates for different parcel types, provided that such resolutions were properly passed at the AGM.

This decision created uncertainty regarding whether parcel owners had any legal recourse when faced with disparate fee structures in strata developments.

Court of Appeal: Reinforcing Equality in Fee Imposition

On 4 October 2019, the Court of Appeal reversed the High Court’s decision. Justice Vernon Ong JCA ruled that:

• The Strata Management Act 2013 mandates that a Joint Management Body must determine and impose a single rate of maintenance fee across all parcels, regardless of use.

• Differentiating rates based on parcel type was found to be unfair, inequitable, and discriminatory, especially since car park parcels already benefited from lower share unit weightage.

This decision was a significant legal milestone and provided much-needed clarity for parcel owners and JMBs/MCs on their obligations.

Federal Court: Finality in Ruling

The JMB and Denflow Sdn Bhd sought leave to appeal to the Federal Court, but their application was dismissed on 21 May 2020. This dismissal cemented the Court of Appeal’s decision as binding precedent, making it a key reference point for future strata property disputes in Malaysia.

Legal Implications of the Menara Rajawali Decision

The consequences of this decision have had far-reaching implications across the strata management landscape:

1. Unified Maintenance Fee Structures

Following the ruling, many JMBs and MCs in Malaysia have realigned their maintenance fee policies to apply a single rate, promoting fairness and compliance with the Strata Management Act 2013.

2. Greater Accountability for JMBs/MCs

This case has reinforced the need for transparent financial practices, including the preparation of audited accounts and justification for all fee decisions. Parcel owners are now more aware of their right to question and challenge unjustified maintenance charges.

3. Legal Recourse for Parcel Owners

Parcel owners now have clear legal grounds to dispute discriminatory fee structures, with the Strata Management Tribunal in Malaysia serving as a cost-effective venue for dispute resolution. Lawyers specialising in strata management disputes, such as a strata property dispute lawyer, can assist owners in initiating claims.

When to Seek Legal Advice

If you’re a parcel owner, JMB, or MC facing issues related to maintenance fee disputes, it’s critical to seek help from a qualified strata management lawyer in Malaysia. Whether you are disputing excessive charges or navigating your responsibilities under the Strata Management Act 2013, legal support from a firm well-versed in tribunal for strata management matters can make a crucial difference.

Conclusion

The Menara Rajawali case sets a powerful precedent that reinforces the legal obligation of management bodies to treat all parcel owners equitably. With the support of a trusted strata law firm in Malaysia, owners and management bodies alike can ensure compliance with the law and uphold fair practices in strata property management.

For tailored legal advice for JMB and MC or representation in the Strata Tribunal in Malaysia, consult a strata management lawyer in Malaysia with proven experience in this field.

👉 Get a free consultation with our experienced team and take legal action with confidence.

📞 Contact Messrs Lui & Bhullar today for a Free consultation.

• 📧 Email: general@luibhullar.com

• 📞 WhatsApp: +60143000970 / +60143000960